All three hold exactly one troy ounce of gold, so none gives you more gold than the others. The American Gold Eagle is 22 karat. The American Gold Buffalo and the 2026 Canadian Gold Maple Leaf are .9999 fine, 24-karat gold. [1] [4] The real differences are purity, issuer, sizes, security features and price. Compare them below, then check the live price of each.
| Coin | Issuer | Gold purity | Fine gold | Diameter | Face value | First issued | Shop |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| American Gold Eagle | U.S. Mint | 22 karat (91.67%) | 1 troy oz | 32.70 mm | $50 | 1986 | 2026Random year |
| American Gold Buffalo | U.S. Mint | .9999 (24 karat) | 1 troy oz | 32.70 mm | $50 | 2006 | 2026Random year |
| Canadian Gold Maple Leaf | Royal Canadian Mint | .9999 (2026 coin) | 1 troy oz | 30 mm | $50 CAD | 1979 | 2026Random year |
Which coin has the most gold?
None. Each 1 oz coin holds one troy ounce of fine gold. [1] [4] The Gold Eagle weighs more, 33.931 grams, because the Mint adds silver and copper on top of the ounce of gold. [1] A higher purity number tells you how pure the metal is, not how much gold the coin holds.
What is the difference between 22-karat and 24-karat gold?
22 karat means 91.67% gold. The Gold Eagle’s alloy is 91.67% gold, 3% silver and the rest copper. [1] 24 karat, or .9999 fine, means 99.99% gold. The Gold Eagle came first, in 1986. [2] The Gold Buffalo followed in 2006 as the first .9999 gold coin the U.S. government ever made. [3] The Maple Leaf started at .999 in 1979 and moved to .9999 three years later. [5] So a random-year Maple Leaf may be .999 or .9999, while the 2026 coin is .9999.
Which one costs the least?
It changes with the market, so we don’t name a winner. To compare fairly:
- Pick the same year terms for all three, such as the three 2026 coins.
- Use the same quantity and the same payment method, card or wire.
- Because each coin holds one ounce, the cheaper coin is also the cheaper ounce of gold.
- Add shipping and any sales tax for your state before you compare totals.
A random-year coin can cost less than a dated one. Our guide to premiums over spot explains the rest of the price.
What sizes can I buy?
At Anchor, the Gold Eagle comes in 1 oz, 1/2 oz, 1/4 oz and 1/10 oz, each as a 2026 or random-year coin. The Gold Buffalo and Gold Maple Leaf are offered in 1 oz only. If you want to buy or sell gold in smaller pieces, see the Gold Eagle sizes.
What security features does each coin have?
The 2026 Maple Leaf has radial lines in its background, a small micro-engraved maple leaf and support for the Royal Canadian Mint’s Bullion DNA system. [4] Bullion DNA covers Gold Maple Leafs dated 2014 and later, so older coins may not have every feature. [6] For the Gold Eagle, note that the Mint changed the reverse design in 2021, so a random-year Eagle may show either the family of eagles or the newer eagle head. [7] A visible feature alone doesn’t prove a coin is genuine.
Can all three go in an IRA?
Yes, as long as a bank or approved trustee holds them. Gold Eagles qualify under the IRS exception for U.S. coins, and the Mint says they can be held in an IRA. [1] [8] Gold Buffalos and Maple Leafs can qualify as gold bullion that meets the IRS fineness rule. [9] A regular purchase from us isn’t an IRA purchase, so talk to your IRA custodian before you buy.
Which should I choose?
It depends on what matters to you:
- Smaller sizes: the Gold Eagle, the only one of the three we offer in fractional sizes.
- The purest gold: the Gold Buffalo or the 2026 Maple Leaf, both .9999 fine.
- A U.S. Mint coin: the Gold Eagle or the Gold Buffalo.
- The newest security features: the 2026 Maple Leaf.
- Price per ounce: compare all three live prices, as shown above.
Which is easiest to sell later?
We can’t promise which coin will get the highest bid when you sell. Before you sell, ask buyers for a current quote for your exact coin, condition and quantity, and compare any fees. See Sell to Anchor for how we buy.
Questions about these three coins
Does a Gold Eagle have less gold than a Gold Buffalo?
No. Both 1 oz coins hold one troy ounce of gold. The Eagle weighs more because of its silver and copper.
Is the Gold Buffalo pure gold?
Yes. It is .9999 fine, 24-karat gold.
Is the Maple Leaf .999 or .9999?
The 2026 coin is .9999. Maple Leafs from the first years were .999, so a random-year coin may be either.
Are these coins legal tender?
Yes. The Eagle and Buffalo carry a $50 U.S. face value and the Maple Leaf a $50 Canadian face value. Their prices follow the gold market.
Can I buy a 1/10 oz Gold Buffalo or Maple Leaf from Anchor?
Not at the moment. We offer those two in 1 oz. The Gold Eagle comes in four sizes.
Which coin is cheapest?
It changes with the market. Compare the live price of each at the same quantity and payment method.
Sources
- U.S. Mint: gold bullion coin specifications
- U.S. Mint: American Eagle program
- U.S. Mint: first pure gold U.S. coins for investors (2006)
- Royal Canadian Mint: 2026 1 oz Gold Maple Leaf
- Royal Canadian Mint: Gold Maple Leaf history
- Royal Canadian Mint: Bullion DNA
- U.S. Mint: the 2021 American Eagle redesign
- IRS Publication 590-A: IRA investment rules and the coin exception
- IRS: collectibles in retirement accounts and the bullion exception